Why user research panels matter - Part One

Sophie Werkshagen shares her experiences of managing a participant panel for a government service, reflecting on why user research panels - and the people who maintain them - matter.

In Defra we design and deliver services that support farming, food production, animal welfare, environmental protection and rural communities across the UK. It’s where I work as a panel manager, supporting user research across these varied and often complex service areas.

When people picture government user research, they often think of the visible parts - the interviews, focus groups and surveys where we hear directly from users. But behind every successful piece of research is the quieter work of research operations, making all this possible.

A key part of that work is looking after external participant panels - sometimes called user panels. A participant panel is a group of people who have agreed to be contacted for user research. These panels give researchers a trusted way to reach the right people, support responsible and well‑governed research and ensure a fair balance of voices are included.

More than just a name

A participant panel is far more than a list of names - it’s a living ecosystem that, with the right care, can keep research thriving and help services grow in the right direction. When panels are nurtured, engagement stays strong and insights stay rich.

Without that ongoing attention, recruitment naturally slows, insights become less reliable, data protection risks increase, and services risk being shaped without the full depth of user voices.

A well‑run panel is the result of steady, thoughtful work. From recruitment and admin to data protection audits and stakeholder trust‑building, these quieter tasks keep the panel reliable and effective.

The power of three

Three key areas align with our core research operations principles:

recruitment and administration – the day-to-day work that keeps everything moving organisational context – the time, resource and incentive considerations that shape how panels can grow governance – data protection, safeguarding and the practices that build trust with participants and the organisation Why panels matter

Panels play a quiet but powerful role in how government services are shaped. The services we explore in user research often touch directly on people’s working lives, livelihoods and wellbeing. In a Defra context, this might include farming regulations, animal welfare licensing, waste management processes or the systems that support food and environmental standards.

When a panel is well managed, the insights it provides help us understand how these services truly operate for the people and businesses who rely on them. That understanding supports both user needs and the legislative frameworks we must work within.

Panels also help ensure we’re hearing from a broad mix of voices. We can’t simply hear from convenient or easy to reach groups. Panels need to reflect the real diversity of the public and industry - whether that’s farmers with limited internet connectivity or busy waste exporters who only have a few minutes to spare. Steady, intentional growth keeps a panel inclusive and relevant.

There’s a wider impact too. Panels help us deliver on:

Diversity and accessibility - making sure voices aren’t just from the ‘easy to reach’ groups. Accountability - ensuring services are developed with fairness, not just for the majority. Impact at pace - giving research teams a way to respond quickly and responsibly to organisational needs.

And sometimes, research isn’t just about shaping the future - it’s about responding to what’s happening right now. When a service goes live, panels give us a way to gather timely, informed feedback so teams can act quickly and confidently.

More information

Sophie Werkshagen is a Research Operations Panel Manager in the Farming and Countryside Programme.

If you’re interested in supporting our user research, please contact the team.

Check out our LinkedIn page for all the latest news, stories and job openings. While you're there, why not give us a follow?

https://defradigital.blog.gov.uk/2026/03/03/why-user-research-panels-matter-part-one/

seen at 09:55, 3 March in Defra digital, data and technology.