What we did
We found that people care deeply about delivering positive outcomes. But our research suggests we find it easier to explain what we are delivering rather than how it contributes to the change we want to see.
We gathered evidence from user research and conversations about outcomes, service performance, and service ownership. We spoke to people working in a range of roles across Defra group and its arm's length bodies. We wanted to understand what helps, and what gets in the way of Defra becoming more outcome focused.
As part of the research, we asked colleagues to describe what an outcome is. Their answers really made us think.
The term can sometimes feel abstract, strategic, or disconnected from day-to-day work. Yet, outcomes are at the heart of what Defra exists to do. Outcomes are the changes Defra wants to achieve for people, nature and the environment. They support Defra’s vision to restore nature, support growth, and improve security.
The ‘golden thread’One theme ran throughout the research: important parts of the system are not always connected in useful ways. We need a better understanding of whether the things we’re doing actually help achieve the change we want in the world. This includes being clearer about the outcomes we're aiming for, introducing new ownership models, improving how we measure performance, and providing better tools to help generate insights to inform decisions. These elements exist, but the connections between them are often fragmented. As one research participant noted:
‘At the moment we're reverse-engineering... services exist, and we're trying to work out how they link to outcomes.’
Defra is a ministerial department supported by 34 agencies and public bodies operating in a complex ecosystem. The problem is not the work itself. It’s that the connections between different areas of work can be weak or difficult to see.
Some of the challenges are below the surfaceReporting burdens, disconnected data, unclear accountability and duplicated work are easy to see. But participants pointed to deeper root causes, including governance, funding, organisational structures, ownership and culture.
Improving dashboards, reports, or evidence measures alone will not solve the underlying problem. Lasting change may depend just as much on shared understanding, trust, collaboration and decision-making as it does on new tools or processes.
We don't all mean the same thingAnother strong theme was that people spend a lot of time trying to understand each other’s language.
Teams use words such as outcomes, services, performance and transformation in different ways. Sometimes we need to agree definitions before we can discuss the work itself.
'I found the language around outcomes and outputs pretty confusing, because frankly, they sound like the same thing, and I had to really think about it.'
When teams have different views of what a service is, or what success looks like, it becomes harder to collaborate, share evidence, prioritise and make investment decisions. Differences in language can reveal something deeper: a lack of shared understanding about how Defra achieves its outcomes.
We're rich in data, but insight is harderInformation is spread across teams, systems and organisations. People must often find, check, combine and interpret it before they can use it.
Many people also feel that measurement focuses more on activity than outcomes.
It is usually easier to count transactions, milestones, and tasks completed than to understand whether they have led to meaningful change. As one research participant put it:
‘We're caring about what we measure rather than measuring what we care about.'
Better insight does not always mean collecting more data. It means connecting the information we already have so people can understand how well we are achieving our outcomes and learn what works. Better insight can also help Defra make more informed investment decisions.
Reasons to be optimisticWhile the findings are challenging, they are also encouraging.
Our research found growing enthusiasm for outcome-focused and service-led working. Participants valued evidence and insight, and many felt that the foundations for change already exist.
Research participants described a future where outcomes, services, performance and decision-making are connected through a much stronger 'golden thread'. In this future, Defra will use evidence and insight in a better way, to evidence what we did, assess the difference it made, and decide what to do next.
Work is already happening across Defra to make these connections stronger. For me, that was the most encouraging finding.
What’s nextWe’re now starting part one of our test-and-learn experiment, focussing on Waste as our first outcome area. We're beginning conversations with people working across Waste to understand how outcomes, policy, services, evidence and decision-making currently connect, and where the golden thread is strong or breaks down.
This will give us a clearer picture of how the system works today and what we might test next to strengthen those connections. Early in the new year, we’ll share another blog about our plans for the experiment and what we’re starting to learn.
More informationAmy Wilson is a senior user researcher in Defra Digital Data Technology and Security. Get in touch with amy.wilson@defra.gov.uk to find out more, share evidence or tell us about similar work elsewhere in government.
If you're interested in finding out more about what we do in Defra Digital Data Technology and Security check out our LinkedIn page for all the latest news, stories and job openings. While you're there, why not give us a follow?
Like what you read? Subscribe to the blog for all the latest updates.
https://defradigital.blog.gov.uk/2026/11/20/how-does-defra-know-its-making-a-difference/
seen at 09:50, 20 November in Defra digital, data and technology.